← Back to Reading

What It Costs to Break Your Mortgage: How Mortgage Penalties Work

By Kerri Carter

If you break your mortgage before the end of your term, you'll usually pay a penalty. It's one of the most dreaded parts of having a mortgage, mostly because people don't know how it's worked out until they're staring at a number. Let's walk through how it works.

When does a penalty apply?

A penalty applies to a closed mortgage (read more about open vs closed mortgages) when you pay off more than your lender allows before your term ends. That can happen when you:

  • Sell your home and don't take your mortgage with you
  • Refinance
  • Switch to another lender in the middle of your term
  • Pay off a lump sum bigger than your prepayment limit

There's no penalty at the end of your term, when your mortgage comes up for renewal.

The two ways a penalty is calculated

Three months' interest. The lender charges you the interest you'd pay over three months on your remaining balance. This is the usual penalty on a variable rate mortgage.

Interest rate differential (IRD). The lender compares your rate with the rate they could lend at today for the time you have left on your term. The bigger the difference, and the longer you have left, the bigger the penalty. On a fixed rate mortgage you usually pay whichever is greater: three months' interest or the IRD.

An example

Say you have a $400,000 balance at 5.00%.

  • Three months' interest: $400,000 x 5.00% divided by 4 is about $5,000.
  • IRD: you have 2 years left, and the lender's rate for a 2-year term today is 4.00%. That's a 1% difference, so $400,000 x 1% x 2 years is $8,000.

On a fixed rate you'd pay the greater amount, so $8,000. This is a simplified example. Each lender has its own formula.

Not all penalties are the same size

Some lenders calculate the IRD in a way that can make the penalty much bigger than you'd expect. How yours is worked out is written in your mortgage contract, so it's worth checking before you sign, not when you're selling.

Ways to avoid or reduce a penalty

  • Wait until renewal. There's no penalty at the end of your term, and you can switch lenders then.
  • Use your prepayment privileges. Paying down your balance before breaking can shrink the penalty.
  • Check if your mortgage is portable. Taking your mortgage to a new home can avoid the penalty.
  • Compare penalties when you choose a lender. Rate isn't the only thing that matters. A lower rate with a much bigger penalty can cost you more.

What about a variable rate?

Variable rate mortgages usually have the smaller, simpler penalty: three months' interest. There's no IRD calculation, so you can work it out ahead of time. That's one reason people who think they might move or refinance sometimes lean toward variable. (There's more on the trade-offs in fixed vs variable mortgages.)

What the penalty doesn't include

The penalty is the biggest cost of breaking a mortgage, but it isn't the only one. You may also pay:

  • A discharge or administration fee to release the old mortgage
  • Legal fees to register the new mortgage
  • Possibly an appraisal for the new one

Ask your lender for the full cost in writing, not only the penalty.

Does it make sense to break?

Sometimes the penalty is worth paying, and sometimes it isn't. It comes down to a comparison: the penalty against what a new rate saves you.

Using the example above, say your penalty is $8,000 and a new rate saves you 1% on $400,000 for the 2 years you have left. That's also $8,000, so you'd break even and gain nothing. If the new rate saved you 2%, you'd save $16,000 and come out $8,000 ahead.

Other options

Some lenders offer a "blend and extend". Your lender blends your current rate with today's rate and extends your term, without a penalty. It can be a way to lower your payments without breaking the mortgage, though you may end up with a longer term than you wanted.

Thinking of breaking your mortgage?

Before you sign anything, reach out and we'll look at the real numbers. I can compare your penalty against what you'd save.

Have a question about your situation?

Send me a message and I'll get back to you personally.

Enjoyed this? Get my newsletter.

Mortgage news, rate updates and tips, straight to your inbox.

By subscribing you agree to receive emails from Kerri Carter, Mortgage Broker. Unsubscribe any time.